<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=8506645149407858&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
Nanobubble Technology
Products & Solutions
About Moleaer
Resource Hub
Recent articles
Want to get nanobubbles? Start the Conversation
©2024 Moleaer Inc. All Rights Reserved.
CASE STUDY · WASTEWATER

Fallbrook WWTP Reduces Aeration Energy Costs by 30%

Moleaer Nanobubble Technology delivered aeration energy savings below historical levels during two 25-day evaluations at Fallbrook Public Utility District’s Wastewater Treatment Plant No. 1 in California.

The plant serves approximately 25,000 residents. During the evaluations, a 1,800 GPM Moleaer nanobubble generator treated an average influent flow of 1.4 million gallons per day.

Aerial view of Fallbrook Public Utility District Wastewater Treatment Plant #1 in Fallbrook, California
FALLBROOK PUBLIC UTILITY DISTRICT,Fallbrook, California, USA
2.7 MGD Permitted flow1.4 MGD Average daily influent flow treated in the pilots1800 GPM Moleaer mobile trailer nanobubble unit25 days Length of each of the two pilot studies
KEY RESULTS

What changed after treatment.

30%

Average aeration energy savings

Compared with the plant’s historical annual aeration operating costs.

60%

More oxygen transferred

FPUD reported the gain after surfactant removal.

45%

Potential reduction in aeration energy demand

The projected energy demand index fell from 100 to 55.

Nearly 2×

Aeration efficiency

FPUD reported this gain in its existing fine-bubble system.

Same footprint

More treatment capacity

Surfactant removal increased capacity within the existing process volume.

Results come from two 25-day pilot studies at Fallbrook WWTP #1. Moleaer offers this information in good faith, without guarantee of performance.

IN THE CUSTOMER'S WORDS
“The data collected ... showed how the adoption of the Moleaer nanobubble technology allowed to nearly double the energy efficiency of our existing fine-bubble aeration system, due to the ability of nanobubble to remove surfactants from the influent wastewater. ”
A FPUD representative,Fallbrook Public Utility District
THE CHALLENGE

Surfactants make wastewater aeration less efficient

At Fallbrook WWTP, surfactants in the incoming wastewater made it harder for the plant’s fine-bubble aeration system to transfer oxygen into the water. The system releases air through diffusers, creating small bubbles that supply dissolved oxygen to the microorganisms that break down pollutants during secondary treatment.

Surfactants can collect at the surface of those bubbles and slow the movement of oxygen into the water. When less of the oxygen supplied by the blowers reaches the microorganisms, the plant may need to deliver more air to maintain the same dissolved oxygen level. That can increase blower energy use and raise the cost of treating the same volume of wastewater.

Moleaer 1800 GPM mobile trailer nanobubble unit beside a wastewater treatment basin
THE SOLUTION

Moleaer nanobubble pre-treatment at the headworks

During two 25-day evaluations, Fallbrook used a 1,800 GPM Moleaer nanobubble generator to treat an average influent flow of 1.4 million gallons per day at the headworks, upstream of the primary clarifiers.

Pretreatment reduced organic and surfactant loads reaching secondary treatment. The team monitored oxygen transfer and other process indicators and compared plant energy use before, during and after the evaluations.

 

See Moleaer’s nanobubble generators
BEHIND THE RESULTS

How the results were measured.

Energy demand falls from an index of 100 to 55

The chart starts at an energy index of 100. Power savings with external pumping are 31. Power savings with the ability to utilize existing pumping are another 14. New energy demand is 55.

The pilot data and the plant’s energy usage before, during and after the pilots were used to assess the impact of nanobubble injection. The result is 45% potential energy savings.

Waterfall chart of energy index: starting energy 100, minus 31, minus 14, new energy demand 55
Energy savings are produced by improved plant efficiency after implementing Moleaer’s nanobubble pre-treatment.
THE OUTCOME

Lower aeration energy costs and more treatment capacity

During the two 25-day evaluations, Fallbrook’s aeration energy cost savings averaged 30% compared with historical aeration operating costs. Reducing surfactant loads also improved oxygen transfer, allowing the plant to increase secondary treatment capacity within its existing basins.

FPUD recommended that other wastewater plants consider Moleaer nanobubble pretreatment to improve energy efficiency and retrofit underperforming aeration systems.

 

SEE THE FULL DATA

Download the full Fallbrook case study

Get the PDF with the pilot results and the energy chart.

Download the case study (PDF) ↓
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

What does this mean for your site?

Why do surfactants hurt aeration in wastewater treatment?

Surfactants suppress the ability of transferring oxygen in activated sludge systems. Approximately 40 to 60 percent of the energy required to dissolve oxygen into wastewater can be attributed to surfactants alone. At Fallbrook, Moleaer nanobubbles reduced the organic and surfactant loads to the secondary process.

How much energy can nanobubbles save in wastewater aeration?

At Fallbrook WWTP #1, aeration energy savings averaged 30% of the plant’s historical annual aeration OPEX. The pilot energy chart shows 45% potential energy savings, with energy demand falling from an index of 100 to 55. These results come from two 25-day pilot studies.

How do nanobubbles improve oxygen transfer in activated sludge?

Nanobubbles remove surfactants from the influent wastewater, according to FPUD. FPUD reported that injecting them in the headworks basin resulted in 60% more oxygen transferred to the process. FPUD also said the energy efficiency of its existing fine-bubble aeration system nearly doubled.

Where do you inject nanobubbles in a wastewater treatment plant?

At Fallbrook, the nanobubbles were injected into a headworks basin upstream of the primary clarifiers. One 1800 GPM nanobubble generator treated an average daily influent flow of 1.4 MGD.

Can nanobubbles increase wastewater treatment capacity without new tanks?

FPUD said that removing surfactants allowed a more efficient oxygen uptake from the activated sludge. That increased the plant’s treatment capacity without the need for additional process volumes, or for equal footprint. The pilots show nanobubble injection increases the treatment capacity of secondary treatment basins.

What did the Fallbrook nanobubble pilot measure?

The team measured dissolved oxygen (DO), pH, oxidation reduction potential (ORP), oxygen uptake rates, nitrification rates, oxygen transfer efficiency and other water quality and operating parameters. They also used the plant’s energy usage before, during and after the two 25-day pilots.

Can nanobubbles retrofit an existing fine-bubble aeration system?

FPUD recommends nanobubble technology as a cost-effective solution to retrofit under-performing aeration systems. At Fallbrook, the existing fine-bubble aeration system nearly doubled its energy efficiency, according to FPUD.

Will my plant get the same results as Fallbrook?

These results come from two pilot studies at one plant. Moleaer offers the information in good faith, without guarantee of performance, and each customer must decide whether it fits their use. Talk to an expert to review your plant.

Let’s talk about your plant

How could nanobubbles fit your wastewater plant?

Tell us about your aeration system and your goals. We will help you find the next step.

Talk to a wastewater expert →